← Back to feed

Why MCP Was Always a Bad Idea?

L4 · DeveloperOpinion & AnalysisHacker News· 9/20/2026

Critical analysis of foundational agent architecture for developers building AI systems.

AI Summary

Argues that MCP (Model Context Protocol) is obsolete because modern LLMs can now call APIs directly without needing specialized protocols.

Read Original
0 upvotes · 0 downvotes · 1 min read

Related Articles

L3 · BuilderOpinion & AnalysisSimon Willison's Blog
MCP was always a bad idea?

Simon Willison defends MCP's value for controlled agent deployments with security, auth, and audit requirements despite full-access terminal agents making it seem obsolete.

L5 · ResearcherOpinion & Analysis@emollick.bsky.social
Ethan Mollick (@emollick.bsky.social): After a brief but institution-eroding slop science era, it increasingly looks like we are going to have 2 revolutions from AI: 1) Everything ever published will be re-read and re-judged in ways that h

Ethan Mollick predicts AI will enable systematic re-evaluation of all published research and accelerate scientific discovery beyond human absorption capacity.

L5 · ResearcherOpinion & AnalysisLessWrong AI
The Lens That Conceals Its Flaws: Nonsense at the Heart of the Sequences

Critique of LessWrong's intellectual influence on AI, arguing the community that shaped AI thinking has conceptual flaws despite its members' roles in frontier labs and alignment research.

L2 · PractitionerOpinion & Analysis@emollick.bsky.social
Ethan Mollick (@emollick.bsky.social): When people talk about AI easily replacing workers, I think about this ethnography of copier repair technicians in the 1990s. Reading it, you see how work is complicated and improvised by workers and

Ethnography of 1990s copier technicians shows work is more complex and improvised than assumed, challenging simplistic AI replacement narratives despite eventual automation.

L2 · PractitionerOpinion & AnalysisSimon Willison's Blog
Anti-Patterns in Software Blogging

Simon Willison shares Michael Lynch's advice against AI-generated blandness in software blogging, urging developers to write with personality.